Be that as it may,
Electric Arc Furnace steelmaking process is an pyrometallurgical process, which with sizeable air infiltration generates complex and harmful emissions through its inherited operating
combustion characteristics.
Furthermore, Electric Arc Furnaces using only
electric arc as the only source of thermal energy, are with respect to the utilization of the
primary energy, very inefficient.
Current state of the art of the convential
Electric Arc Furnace apparatus and operating practices generate substantial emissions in the form of dust and hot fumes.
Carbon monoxide CO, resulting from incomplete oxidation of carbon is a poisonous gas.
It is also believed, it supports depletion of
ozone layer around our
planet, causing increased occurrence of
skin carcinoma.
However, compliance with such demands would result in large investment costs with consequent increase of the cost of produced steel.
Currently, the conflict between ideals of environmentalists and industry in developed countries is growing rapidly.
Furthermore,
air pollution originating by the virtue from metallurgical processes of iron and steelmaking, and increased by energy inefficient processes may have very grave consequences which at present are even hard to foretell.
Distress signals have already appeared of dangers that await mankind if urgent measures are not taken to protect the environment against
pollution and energy inefficient processes.
Waste smokes and gases formed by industrial processes have become a problem of vital importance;
overall prime energy inefficiency of currently operated processes and systems.
Energy cost crisis which began not so long ago in North America is making existing situation even worse, threatening to spread
world wide.
When considering energy utilization efficiency, noticeably aggravating is the fact, that more than 50% of the currently operating ferro-metallurgical industrial processes, consuming massive quantities of
electric energy--of which at least a half is generated by burning large quantities of
fossil fuel--are extremely inefficient in relation to the
primary energy.
This is already done, regretfully it is not yet exploited to its full potential.
Electric energy used via
electric arc for creating high temperature heat source for melting in Electric Arc Furnace is extremely inefficient with respect to the primary energy; this is valid especially when
electricity is generated via burning of the coal in the boiler, producing the steam for the
turbine.
In majority of developed countries, the
electric energy is not available and with price deregulation it is too expensive to be used for profitable steelmaking.
On the other hand, the main obstacle to the introduction of the more primary energy efficient high temperature sources for steelmaking from scrap is the fact, that all so far known steelmaking processes using primarily
fossil fuel such as natural gas and oil as substitute, required a completely new or substantial and costly modification of the furnace design and reconstruction of the surrounding auxiliaries.
That means, that so far known, more primary energy efficient metallurgical furnace design could not simply and directly replace the Electric Arc Furnace.
Further
continuation of firing of the burner is extremely inefficient and wasteful (after being fired over 20% of the melting time the efficiency of the stationary burners usually drop from about 75-80% in the begin of the melting process, to about 20-30%).
This is the actual situation, although there have been during last 20 years, "simple" but more or less successful burners using coal combusted by air; recently performed practical tests have shown insufficient temperature of coal-air
flame.
An other problem which has not yet been solved to the satisfaction of the steelmakers, is the--as much as mechanized as possible--introduction-injection
system and apparatus for carbonaceous (coal,
coke,
anthracite) and
slag forming (CaO) materials into the steelmaking Electric Arc Furnace.
It appears, that the main reason why none of the several available systems has not emerged as a leader is the fact that none of them has functioned properly at all of time.
Another, functionally inadequate characteristics, common to almost all of the state of the art lance systems, is that most of them have coal and
oxygen introduced through two independent pipes.
This arrangement is not capable of mixing properly pulverized coal and
oxygen before entering the slag-steel interface.
In other words, the Table II., is attesting beyond any reasonable doubt, that any Electric Arc Furnace using
electricity generated at a Power
Plant burning coal or natural gas is extremely inefficient with respect to primary energy contained in natural gas or coal.
However, cost of producing the electricity from coal is increased by several additional charges depending on location and resulting in its higher a commercial price.
Unfortunately, the lower price of electricity generated by using the coal instead of natural gas, is many times overcome by the fact that
combustion of the coal with air, produces about 2.2 times more CO.sub.2 and CO in addition to 1.4 times more of NO.sub.x and about 38 scf /
ton of SO.sub.2 (natural gas does not produce SO.sub.2).