At the same time, the Industry also discovered the existence of large quantities of heavy and light hydrocarbon compound mixtures that were nonconventional in structure and were so enmeshed in the complex material matrixes that the hydrocarbon molecule compounds contained therein could not be extracted economically.
Although the
shale oil proved to be a very suitable hydrocarbon product, its cost of production was well in excess of the market price of similar products; thus this situation proved to be uneconomical.
Additional development and investment was not justified at that time.
However some oil companies were concerned about the dangers in using explosives as a means of extending the productive life of depleting oil fields; and, in the late nineteen forties, the practice of using highly-pressured water and sand mixtures to produce fissures or fractures in the pay-zone areas began.
However, during the period when the application of
hydraulic fracturing was becoming more wide spread, its growth, technologically and operationally, was carried out in a very haphazard, hit and miss, ad hoc manner.
Many of the improvements that were made were the result of unscientifically developed
trial and error attempts to improve the rate of production in an
oil well as well as trying to extend the economic life of established oil fields.
The best example of this unscientific approach, in trying to solve specific
processing problems, is what was occurring in the proper selection and use of various types of proppants in the
hydraulic fracturing process.
Without the proper proppants that are strong enough and correctly sized to keep the fissures continuously open, the well's
production rate will decline rapidly as proppant fines and softer material particles fill up the fissures.
These will decrease the rate of flow and ultimately block the flow of hydrocarbons into the well bore.
The key issue here is that the proper proppant that should be used in a
hydraulic fracturing process is the single most important factor that is needed in achieving and maintaining the proper “voids ratio” that is needed in the pressurized water fractured channels to be able to realize the full benefit of the hydraulic fracturing process.
With the introduction of steerable vertical and horizontal drilling equipment together with very
high pressure fracturing pumps (called by some “intensifiers”), the oil industry then applied the same hydraulic fracturing techniques that had been successfully developed and used in vertical
oil well hydraulic fracturing operations and applied these same procedures to the well bores that were horizontally drilled in the deep shale formations but with less than satisfactory results.
It was not until the industry started to realize that the traditional principles of
petroleum technology were not fully applicable to the newly developed attempts to extract entrapped liquid and gaseous hydrocarbons from mineral rock formations that did allow them to flow freely even in deep high temperature and
high pressure locations.
A smaller size proppant would not be as effective and this would result in a significant reduction in the amount of hydrocarbon product that could be produced.
Much of the proppant remains behind in these channels; however, a significant amount comes out in the back-flow water.
Treatment and / or disposal of this flow-back are significant issues for the industry.
Ohio quakes put pressure on use of fracturing.
Another significant micro-
organism type problem is the possible presence of a strain of microbes that have an affinity for seeking out and digesting any free
sulfur or
sulfur bearing compounds and producing
hydrogen sulfides that must be removed from any
product gas stream because it is a highly dangerous and carcinogenic material.
In addition to the possibility of micro-organisms multiplying and blocking the flow of hydrocarbon product, the presence of dissolved solids in the water solution can also be a problem in the injected water mixture.
In order to avoid this condition, attempts are made in current industry practice to have the dissolved solids coalesce and attach themselves to the suspended or other colloidal particles present in the water mixture to be removed before injection in the well; however, those efforts are only partly effective.
The use of ultra
violet light in conjunction with reduced amounts of chemical
biocide has proven to be only partially effective in killing water borne micro-organisms.
Both these systems, however, lack the intensity and strength to effectively kill all of the water-borne micro-organisms with only one weak short time
residence exposure and with virtually no residual effectiveness.
Also, some companies use low-frequency or low-strength electro-magnetic wave generators as
biocide / coalescers; however, these too have proven to be only marginally effective.
In some examples, the injecting of the particulate is decreased when the slagging material
viscosity is so low that the flow rate through the
kiln is too fast for fusing of proppant material.